A Byrd Sextant Restored

30 05 2009

This post is preceded by “Bubble illumination of Mk V and AN 5851 bubble sextants” ,  “Refilling Mark V/AN5851 bubble  chambers” ,  “Overhaul of MkV/An5851 bubble chamber” and “AN5851-1 : jammed shades carrousel”

I recently acquired  a Brandis nautical vernier sextant without case, telescope, or any shades. It appeared to have an extra mirror in front of the horizon mirror and I recognised it as an early bubble sextant of the type used by the then Commander Richard Byrd on his claimed flight to the North Pole in 1926. There are several magazine photographs extant that show Byrd in posed pictures, using a similar sextant, this one, for example:

Almirante_Richard_E__Byrd

K Hilding Beij, writing in the Bureau of Standards Report 198, Astronomical Methods in Aerial Navigation in about 1926, refers to the sextant as a “Byrd sextant”, though Luis de Florez, a prolific  inventor, claimed priority. He had filed for a patent for exactly this type of bubble sextant in March 1919 and he was granted US Patent number 1,536,286 in May 1925. My sextant looked like this when I received it:

100_2772

The one Byrd is using is a full-size Brandis vernier quintant with an arc of 180 mm radius reading to 30 seconds, whereas my example is unusually small for a vernier quintant, having an arc radius of only 140 mm, also reading to 30 seconds, so my hopes of possessing an historic instrument were disappointed (but see postscript). Nevertheless, it is a rare and early instrument dating from about 1920 and I felt it was worthwhile  to restore it to working order. As I have no access to original instruments, I did not set out to make exact copies of the attachments that make a nautical quintant into an aeronautical one, but I did follow the same principles, while retaining all the original parts. Needless to say, I dismantled it completely to begin with, and cleaned all the individual parts. A photograph of the restored instrument will perhaps best help to explain its workings.

100_2796

The optical path for the heavenly body is as usual, via the index mirror and silvered half of the horizon mirror. An ordinary spirit level vial is held in a carrier and viewed via an auxiliary mirror set at 45 degrees above it, through the plain half of the horizon mirror. The image of the bubble would be out of focus viewed directly through the x 2 Galilean telescope and so an extra, semicircular, lens is interposed in the light path to bring it into sharp focus. The auxiliary mirror may be swung downwards to allow direct view of the natural horizon by pressing a spring-loaded catch.

The sensitivity of the vial has to be carefully chosen. If too sensitive, it is never at rest when the instrument is held in the hand and if not sensitive enough it is not possible to get meaningful results. I settled for one where the bubble moves 2 mm for 6 minutes change in level. This is of the same order of sensitivity as most other bubble sextants.  The bubble is illuminated from one end and, to try to get even illumination, the vial is painted white over most of its surface, including the end distant from the lamp. This has parallels in the lighting of some circular bubble cells, where an attempt is often made to conduct the light around the periphery of the cell with some sort of light guide. The next photograph shows a view of the lighted vial through the telescope (the view is somewhat more extensive than this in reality).

100_2792

In sextants with circular bubble cells, one usually aims either to centre the body in the bubble or to align it with its equator, but this cannot be done with a linear cell, so a more-or-less central datum line is used and the sextant adjusted so that when the bubble is centred, the datum line lies on the horizontal. As is usual for a Galilean telescope, each half of the objective lens “sees”  its own half of the field of view (compare this with the inverting or astronomical telescope, where obscuring half the objective simply cuts out half the total light). Thus, the auxiliary, semicircular lens in the telescope attachment sees the left half-field and  is used to bring the bubble into focus by sliding back or forth.

The heavenly body is seen on the other half-field and, as is usual, there is a narrow band of overlap where both the sky and the horizon or bubble may be seen together. I have not made any significant trials as yet, but it is relatively easy on dry land to align a star, the moon or the sun with the datum line while trying to keep the bubble centred. However, the instrument gives no indication of lateral tilt and in an aircraft the results must have been very uncertain.

The scale lighting is particularly good. A shaded lamp shines via a standard diffusing screen on to the scales, which are viewed through a simple magnifier. Unlike many such systems it gives a very even illumination so that the main and vernier scales are seen with equal contrast, making reading relatively easy and rapid.

100_2802

The handle seems to be a modified early Brandis battery handle. Power is now from an external source. Scale lighting is via the original press switch, while the bubble unit is switched by a rather crude rotary switch on the front of the handle, seen in the general arrangement photo above. The following photo shows the wiring layout, pretty well as found except for the decayed silk covered wire.

Byrd handle

I have coated the parts that I have made – telescope and attachment, and vial carrier – with modern paint. The original paintwork on the rest of the instrument is careworn and I cannot help but feel that it would look better for a fresh coat of paint. I would repaint a more modern instrument in the same condition and wonder how readers might feel about that. Is it sufficiently “historic” to preserve it as found? Would repainting it devalue it in some way.”? After all, noone is likely to mistake it for a modern fake, repainted or not.

The index shades, by the way, I borrowed from another Brandis sextant, so that if anyone has a spare set of Brandis or US Navy Mark II index shades that I can beg or buy, I should be glad to hear from them.

Post script, 11 September 2015.

When I wrote this post, I thought Byrd was holding a larger sextant than mine, but an enquiry led me to look more closely at the structure of the sextant he is shown holding and I now believe that he is holding the same type of sextant that I describe, viz.a survey sextant of 140 mm radius.





AN 5851-1. Jammed shades carrousel

14 05 2009

This post is preceded by “Bubble illumination of Mk V and AN 5851 bubble sextants” ,  “Refilling Mark V/AN5851 bubble  chambers” and “Overhaul of MkV/An5851 bubble chamber”

I have been asked about the carrousel that holds the various shade glasses in the AN5851 bubble sextant. This is one of my least favourite bubble sextants, heavy (2.5 kg), awkward to hold and the optical path complicated by the inclusion of a horizon prism. The near indestructability of the case was bought at the expense of more weight (6.4 kg!).

My correspondent reported that his carrousel was jammed and wondered whether its associated spring could be the cause. Here’s how you get at it.

1) Remove 4 screws (circled in white, below) from the black plastic cover and remove it. Take the opportunity to clean the copper electrical contacts inside it, that carry current to the scales-illumination lamp.

Carrousel 0

2) Loosen, but do not remove, the two screws that hold the black shade cover over the carrousel. Then dislocate it upwards and pull it outwards.

Carrousel 1

Carrousel 2

 This reveals the shouldered screw that holds the carrousel on to a complicated little alloy casting that also mounts the astigmatiser. There is a brass spring washer between the head of the screw and the alloy carrousel body. Removing the black shade cover also loosens the leaf spring’s attachment, and in the unlikely event that a disordered spring is the cause of stiffness, this should allow the carrousel to revolve freely.

Carrousel 3

3) Corrosion between the central screw and the carrousel is much the most likely cause of stiffness. It is not easy to get at the screw slot without removing the index prism (best left alone) or improvising a bent screw driver from a piece of steel strip or grasping the head of the screw in a narrow pair of pliers. However, if you swing the astigmatiser out of the way, you will be able to get at the two screws that hold the casting into which it is inserted, to the frame of the sextant. If there is corrosion, and you need to use a lot of force, you may break off the screw where it enters the casting or damage the casting. It is much safer to apply a little thin oil between the screw head and the carrousel. Allow a few hours for it to penetrate and then gently work the carrousel free. Be prepared patiently to repeat the process several times. Remove the central screw only if it loosens easily.

Replacement is the reverse of dis-assembly.





Overhaul of Mk V/ AN5851 sextant bubble chamber

20 12 2008

This post is preceded by “Bubble Illumination of Mk V and AN 5851 Bubble Sextants” and “Refilling Mark V and AN5851 Bubble  Chambers”

The preceding post dealt only with refilling a bubble chamber that was otherwise clean and tidy. This post covers dismantling for cleaning and refitting the glasses. You will need an electric iron, a pencil, a screwdriver, some flake shellac (from a decorating shop or French polisher), some xylene, a syringe (preferably glass) and needle or a fine pipette.

Start by removing the bubble chamber assembly from the sextant as in the previous post. Remove the taper plug. Remove the air chamber (4 screws from underneath), carefully preserving the gasket if you can. The control unit unscrews by using a wrench on the octagonal metal rim. At this point, it is wise to be wearing an apron with its skirt clipped to your bench or table, as there is a ball bearing with a hole pierced through its centre just  waiting to fall onto the floor and be lost for ever. Dont let this happen to you. It is difficult to drill holes through small balls. Empty the control unit into the bubble chamber by repeated pressing and shake out as much xylene as you can. You should now have reached the state shown in the following photograph:

dis-assembled-bubble

Also remove the four tiny countersunk screws on the underside and carefully prise the illuminating annulus free. The paint beneath is radium paint and, while it no longer glows in the dark, the radioactivity from the contained radium is still present and is best removed, before replacing it with modern photo-luminescent paint.

See https://sextantbook.com/2008/12/09/bubble-illumination-of-mk-v-and-an-5851-bubble-sextants/  for some advice on how to do this.

luminous-annulus

Meanwhile, your electric iron, carefully secured in some way with the sole upermost, can be warming up. The maximum setting seems to be just the right temperature. For those lucky people with laboratory hotplates, the temperature of my iron cycles between 160 and 182 celsius. Place the stripped down bubble chamber on the hot iron and do something else for five minute while it heats up and softens the shellac that is holding everything in place. You can check whether it is hot enough by touching the chamber somewhere with a flake of shellac to see whether it melts.

When the right temperature  has been reached, hold the chamber in one hand with a thick towel or heavy leather glove and unscrew the bottom retaining ring. For this you can use the correct tool, a pin wrench, or a piece of 1.5 mm metal strip previously filed to fit the slots. Then rap the chamber sharply on a wooden bench and with luck the bottom glass will fall out. When your hand has stopped hurting from holding a very hot object,  turn over the chamber and unscrew the other retaining ring. While everything is still hot, push out the top lens with a pencil from underneath.

Allow everything to cool down and then soak the glasses and retaining rings in alcohol while you chip away as much old shellac as you can from the chamber body. If you are patient, you could instead soak all the parts overnight in alcohol and rinse in the morning with clean alcohol. Everything should now look something like this:

lenses-out

There is a very tiny passageway between the air and bubble chambers and you should make sure that this is perfectly clear of shellac, as it enter the bubble chamber partly under the bottom glass and can easily be completely blocked by stray shellac.

Return the bubble chamber to the hot iron with the top of the chamber uppermost and when it is hot enough, carefully apply a ring of shellac to the flat lens seat. Do this by picking up flakes about 5 to 10 mm long in a pair of fine forceps and smear as you dab. When the ring is complete, align the etched line of the top glass with the fore and aft line of the chamber (the bubble control is aft and the air chamber to the left) and drop the lens into place. You will get perhaps one chance at realigning it if you get it wrong, before the glass gets too hot to touch. The lens goes in convex side up. The concave side has a flat annulus ground on it and this goes downwards.

The official manual instructs one now to apply pressure to the lens with a jig until the shellac has cooled somewhat, when the retaining ring is screwed into place. If you have the means, you can improvise a jig like mine, shown in the next photograph, or use a Mark I pencil as shown in the one after,  to apply a little downward pressure to make sure there is a complete ring of shellac beneath the glass. Having tried both on a variety of bubble chambers, I now use a pencil and screw down the retaining ring while everything is still nice and hot, and I bet the WW II technicians did too.

jig

100_2216

Allow the chamber to cool down and check the inside for loose flakes or little teardrops of shellac on the underside of the top glass. The latter can be chipped off easily and the job completed with a wipe of alcohol. The cleaner the inside is, the better the bubble will move and the clearer the view, so do it now, as you won’t be able to after the next step, which is to fit the bottom glass, following the same procedure as for the top. When applying the bottom ring of shellac, take special care to keep it away from the mouth of the capillary passage to the air chamber, but make sure there is some more peripherally to complete the seal.

When everything has cooled down again, chip away shellac from the outside of the glasses, clean up and refit the control and air chamber, the reverse of dis-assembly. Take care that the hole through the ball lines up with the passage into the bubble chamber from the control.

The last photograph actually shows an A10 vapour pressure chamber being resealed. The original seals were lead washers and don’t work for me when re-used. You can mess about with O rings that cause alterations in the optical path length and sometimes dissolve in xylene, or search for the ideal material with which to replace the lead washers, or you can make a really good job of it with shellac.

I hope to have an e-book overhaul manual for the A10/10A ready by the end of February, 2009. Meanwhile, you could enjoy reading The Naked Nautical Sextant and its Intimate Anatomy (but first you have to buy it).





Refilling Mark V / AN5851 bubble chambers

18 12 2008

This post is preceded by “Bubble Illumination of Mk V and AN 5851 Bubble Sextants”

Mark V is the US Navy designation for the AN5851 sextant. Early models were fitted with vapour pressure bubbles, which are hard, but not impossible to refill. This post will deal with only the somewhat easier air bubble models, which are distinguished by having a cylindrical air chamber projecting from the top left hand side of the chamber and, because I want at least to start to answer a request for details before Christmas intervenes, I’m sticking to the simplest case. This is where there is a bubble of some sort present and the fluid and glasses appear clear. If there are particles floating around in the fluid, or it has completely dried up leaving a powdery film inside the chamber, a full overhaul will be needed.

At the front of the chamber, you will see projecting a peg about 2 mm in diameter. This is a tapered pin that occupies a tapered hole through which the chamber was filled. To remove it, remove the chamber and eye lens assembly as described in the previous post. Then grasp the end of the pin in a pair of pliers and pull directly in line with it while twisting. It should come out without too much trouble, unless you pull and twist out of line, when it may break off and leave you in deep trouble, the solution for which will be covered in a future post.

100_2210

Once the pin is out, you can refill the chamber with xylene using a hypodermic syringe and needle, if you can locate a glass syringe. You can use a disposable plastic one, but the xylene attacks the plastic and the syringe rapidly becomes very stiff to operate. An alternative is to use a glass pipette with the end drawn out to a fine tube of about 1 mm diameter. This is what I now use. Some decorating shops stock xylene in bulk and may be prepared to sell you 500 ml or so. It will last you a long time. An alternative suggested, with which I have no experience, is Zippo or Ronsonol cigarette lighter fluid. You should not use alcohol, as the glasses  have been sealed with shellac, which is soluble in alcohol.

When the chamber is full, temporarily replace the taper pin with a pushing and screwing motion,  hold the chamber with the air chamber downwards and press repeatedly on the control knob until no more air comes into the bubble chamber. This displaces air from the bellows into the bubble chamber. Then refill the bubble chamber . At this point you can  replace the taper pin using a firm pushing and screwing motion. Do not tap it in with a hammer. It may be necessary to experiment a little to get the right amount of fluid. It should be possible to remove the bubble altogether, so that sights using the natural horizon can be taken. If the bubble cannot be entirely removed, remove the taper pin and add a little more xylene.

To empty the air out of the bubble chamber to reduce the size of the bubble, hold with the air chamber upwards while pressing repeatedly on the bubble control knob until you have a bubble of the desired size. Pressing forces air into the air chamber through a tiny capillary tube and when you release, xylene passes into the bubble chamber. To get a larger bubble, hold with the air chamber downwards while operating the control. 

If you cannot get a bubble at all, the air chamber may be completely full of xylene and you will have to remove a little, the capillary passage between the bubble and air chambers may be blocked by debris( clear with a piece of fine wire), or the hole in the ball that seals the bellows unit to the bubble chamber may be misaligned (see next post).

Do let me know if you find this post useful and ask if something is unclear. Consider, too,  buying yourself a gift of The Nautical Sextant…





Bubble illumination of Mk V and AN 5851 bubble sextants

9 12 2008

A recent posting to the Sextants@yahoogroups.com asked about renewing the illumination of  the US Navy Mk V bubble chamber. I think I am correct in saying that this is identical to the AN 5851 chamber illumination. A little oddly, there was no attempt to have electrical illumination. Instead, self-luminous radium paint was used. Now radium has a half life of nearly 1600 years, so plainly it is not the radium that has decayed, but the luminescent compound mixed with it. Replacing the paint with a modern photoluminescent paint is not difficult, but  some minimal commonsense precautions should be taken to avoid swallowing or breathing in the old paint.

The bubble chamber, incidentally, is one of the easier ones to service, as the manufacturer sensibly provided a plug in the form of a taper pin to allow refilling. The top and bottom of the inside of chamber need to be scrupulously clean before refilling and this is not so simple.

Let us assume, however, that you have a bubble in a chamber that is free from debris. The first step is to remove the chamber together with the eyepiece prism by removing the three screws shown in the following photograph:

step-one

Removal of the eyepiece prism is completed by inverting the bubble chamber and removing two more screws, as shown in the next photograph:

step-two

The radium paint is contained beneath the black washer-like disc that is secured by four tiny countersunk screws. Removing these allows it to be carefully prised from its seat. The paint can then be removed from the underside of the washer and from the underside of the bubble chamber bottom glass by softening  and dissolving the paint with acetone. Certainly you should take every precaution not to inhale or swallow any. How you dispose of the paint is up to you. The level of radioactivity is low and there is only a small quantity, so disposing in the sea is unlikely to do any harm to anyone.  A local university physics department or the radio therapy unit of a hospital might be prepared to advise.

Replace the paint on the underside of the washer with, first, a layer of white paint and then a layer of modern photoluminescent paint. A layer of the latter (but not the white paint) can also be applied to the bottom glass beneath the washer – the thicker the layer of the luminescent paint, the better the illumination. Re-assembly is the reverse of dis-assembly.

To charge the photoluminescent paint, shine a bright light, say, a 40 watt bulb, onto the index prism for 5 minutes or so. How long the light lasts depends on how long you charge the paint for and on the grade of the paint.

You might wonder whether overpainting the radium paint with a paint containing copper-doped zinc sulphide would renew the radioluminescence. The answer seems to be “No” because the alpha particles emitted by the radium penetrate poorly and the ZnS.Cu needs to be mixed intimately with the radium.

Post me a comment if you would like me to deal with cleaning and refilling the bubble chamber. It is not as simple as replacing the paint, but needs no very special tools, notwithstanding the instructions given in the original overhaul manual.





AIRCRAFT BUBBLE SEXTANTS

17 11 2008

I have recently been asked by a reader whether I plan to write a similar book about aircraft bubble sextants, such as the US A10 and A12 sextants of the Second World War. The answer is “perhaps when I have caught my breath after writing the Nautical Sextant.”

However, readers may be interested in my Mark IXA Sextant – A reconditioning manual, also available as an e-book. The Mark IX series of bubble sextants served the Royal Air Force right through WW II and beyond. Thousands of these instruments survive and in the view of many, including me, it was the best designed of all the bubble sextants ever made. I have recently revised the manual and added a supplement on the Mark IX. If you’re interested, contact me.

I have now (2020) written overhaul manuals on the A10, A12 and the SNO-T sextants. I also have official maintenance manuals on several others  to refer to when people get stuck with an overhaul.